Training Your Dog - Pros And Cons Of Control Tools
Topics: dog training, dog, dogs
At times the differences between training and control is too easily lost. Training involves the use of commands and hand gestures, with leashes or treats, to gain desired behavior. On the other hand, using choke or ‘no-bark’ collars, electronic fences and similar devices is for control.
Control isn’t always a negative thing. Dogs typically have and seek a social hierarchy in which one is the alpha (leader) and in any human-dog pair the human has to take that role. If this doesn’t happen the result is destruction of property, conditions that are unsafe for dogs and humans, a maladjusted dog and much frustration on the part of the dog owner.
Choke collars were invented to aid in obtaining control. Dogs, like humans, are each individual and possess their own separate personalities. Some are naturally more assertive or slower to learn. For the dogs that aren’t responsive to a regular leather or nylon collar, a metal choke collar can offer increased discouragement from pulling and leaping.
The possible problem is that if used improperly — which is all too easy to do - they can be counter-productive and sometimes even unsafe. Choke collars fit only one way and when fitted should allow from one to three fingers gap between the neck and the collar. Three for a larger dog, one for smaller. Normally, a collar two inches longer than the neck circumference will do.
If used improperly, however, choke collars may pinch the skin - creating hot spots that will be made worse if the dog scratches them. Choke collars can also unintentionally squeeze the trachea. An instantaneous pull-and-release is not injurious, although because of the way it is designed creates discomfort, however for dogs that are inclined to pull against the leash this movement is not easy to do. Choke collars are generally not recommended, particularly for small dogs.
Prong collars are not as dangerous as they seem, but - in this trainer’s view - have virtually no redeeming characteristics. The one beneficial feature of the design is their restricted diameter - they can only close down so far. Then again, a dog with such a strong tendency to pull that prong collars look attractive to use, needs more than a quick fix consisting of choking and poking. That animal requires dedicated attention and behavior modification training.
Halter collars, which wrap around both the neck and the muzzle, but doesn’t prevent panting or impair drinking can give the owner additional control. The downside is, since they don’t restrict biting or grasping, much of their potential value is gone. An ordinary leash and collar, or even a chest halter may be preferable.
‘No-bark’ collars will occassionally help with those dogs that continue to bark long after the initial impetus is gone. Barking is a natural response to possible threats and is also used to attract attention when the dog becomes separated from the pack. However, for reasons not completely understood, some individual dogs continue to bark for extended periods of time or at the slightest irritation.
Electronic collars that dissuade barking come in two types: noise and shock. Noise collars give off a short, unpleasant sound that distracts and is intended to discourage continued barking.
Shock collars produce a short but painful electric shock that can be repeated and lengthened during prolonged and/or persistent barking. Objective tests of their effectiveness demonstrate varied results, however. As with prong collars, any dog requiring one would probably benefit more from careful, professional help.
At times quick fixes are tempting and have their place - until they become substitutes for more beneficial (both to trainer and dog) long-term training. Investing the time to learn to get the attention of your dog and compliance without excessive reliance on control devices is always better. The end result is a saner owner and happier dog.
Jane Saeman loves dogs and strives to keep other dog lovers informed. A whole world awaits other dog lovers.
Find out how cute the dog in your life is at www.PicturesofmyDogs.com
Previous Articles Highlighter:
How To Teach Your Puppy To 'Sit-Stay' (1)
Say "No," then walk him back to exactly where he was sitting. Again, command "Sit," signal him and tell him to "Stay." He will probably think that "Stay" means just that and he may want to get comfortable and lie down.
Dog Training - Pet Tricks Training (2)
If this is a desired trick, watch for the beginnings of the behavior, then be prepared to associate it with a hand gesture and voice command, then reward immediately. Teaching the basic 'sit', 'come', etc commands are usually simple.
Dog Training - How To Stop Chewing (3)
Stay alert and keep a cool head even when they've just chewed a hole in that new carpet. That's expensive and annoying, but carpet can be replaced. Your relationship with your pet can't.
Dog Training - Crate Training Pros And Cons (4)
Advocates assert that crate trained animals will do better on car, train or plane trips. They're used to the confinement and they have a familiar-smelling environment with them during a time of stress.
The Importance Of Enrolling Your Dog In The Right Training Class (5)
In addition, classroom training helps to prepare both the owner and the dog for participation in the Obedience Trials at dog shows. Training classes may be held independently at an obedience club when sponsored by another organization, with the exception of privately owned and professional groups.
Does A Dog Learn Through Many Repetitions Of A Training Activity? (6)
That some dogs may take longer to build an attraction to the ball is not due to a need for repetition, but because the prey instinct isn't yet turned on.
Do Dogs Learn By Trial And Error? (7)
The dog is being informed through his nervous system whether he's on the right track or not. He reacts based on that immediate sensation and his actions are very often effective simply because he's responding to the way nature is organized, his instinctive reflexes mirroring this same organization.
Does Your Dog Have Problems With Fighting Other Dogs? (8)
Although past events might have had disastrous effects on the dog and might have affected his mind and emotional makeup, it would have to be the owner who is psychoanalyzed to find the answer to the dog's problems.
The Smartest Way To Buy Tattoo Designs (9)
What is your budget for a tattoo? The complexity of the design, color, size, detail, line art, quality of the tattoo designs and the skill of the tattoo artist would the platform for you to calculate your budget.
Dog Training - Training Assertive Dogs (10)
Topics: dog training, dog, dogs As descendants from wolf packs, dogs have and seek a natural hierarchy in which some are dominant (alphas) and others follow. Struggles among young pups to sort of who is which start early, in some cases three weeks after birth.
Newer Articles Highlighter:
How To Have An Unforgettable Tour (1)
3. If you are a beach bum, get a handful of sand along with little shells and pour them into a jar. Label the jar with the name of the beach from where you got them.
Vacation Home Rentals Compared To Staying At A Hotel (2)
There's no sharing the internet with the rest of the hotel guest, just your family to share with. If you compare the cost of a hotel room to a vacation home, you truly get a better deal with the vacation home in most cases.
Creative Ways To Display Art Work (3)
People use spray paint to add a touch of color to the chain to blend it into the wall coloring. People are then exposed to art that seems to be floating on the wall with nothing to support it in any direction.
Golf Swing Technique - Tips To Improve Your Swing (4)
It just makes sense. A strong fit body is going to make more of an impression on a long distance drive than a body out of shape. On the other hand, getting fit for golf is different than preparing for a running marathon.
Are You Considering Online Motorcycle Shopping? (5)
Every bike may seem the same but they will never cost the same due to the force of their engines. The force of the engine is what determines efficacy, value and rapidity of one bike over the other.
The 10 Steps To Safely And Effectively Hang A Tree Stand (6)
Other hunters prefer to be 50-100 yards to increase the chances of an accurate kill shot. Finding suitable trees will also be a deciding factor. If hunting with a bow, 15-25 yards away is what most hunters look for.
Discovering Rare Collectibles (7)
Knowledge, knowledge, knowledge and set those buying limits. I can only tell you that books are about the best way to learn. There are so many fields in this hobby and it takes years to know what each item is and it's value and you still have to look items up as to their current value.
Time Sharing Your Vacation Home (8)
The problem that most of them face is the upkeep of these second homes. It just takes too much work for a place which they only use a few weeks per year.
Making Great Hunting Dogs (9)
Some characteristics of certain breeds make them naturally right for certain types of hunting and you will have the most success choosing the right breed for your hunting style. You will find that Retrievers are great for retrieving downed ducks or geese in water, whereas scent hounds are excellent at tracking game by smell, even in extreme conditions.
Keeping Your Dog Safe In Hot Weather (10)
Provide shade for your dog. Buy a tarp or a sheet from the thrift store and put it up if necessary. It's a lot cheaper than a vet bill.
Permalink to Training Your Dog - Pros And Cons Of Control Tools